7 Best Waterproof Mascaras That Won't Budge, No Matter What

Are you looking to keep your lash look locked in, come what may? Diving into the world of waterproof mascaras might be your best bet. These hardworking formulas can withstand everything from spontaneous swims to teary-eyed moments, ensuring your eyes stay picture-perfect no matter the occasion. But with so many options on the market, it can be tricky to determine which one will truly stand the test of time. Let's take a closer look at 7 top-performing waterproof mascaras that are built to last – you might be surprised by what you discover.

Key Takeaways

• Eyeko Beach Waterproof Mascara delivers impressive 24+ hour waterproof performance and is infused with nourishing coconut oil for a vegan formula.

• Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara provides a cruelty-free, smudge-proof formula that is suitable for wear in hot and humid climates.

• Clinique High Impact Mascara applies and washes off easily without clumping, delivering long-lasting wear without smudges or flakes.

• CLIO Kill Lash Superproof Mascara offers a smudge-free, clump-free formula that volumizes and separates lashes while effectively holding the curl.

• L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Waterproof Mascara builds lashes up to 4X their natural thickness with a waterproof, smudge-resistant formula.

Eyeko Beach Waterproof Mascara

For those who lead an active lifestyle, the Eyeko Beach Waterproof Mascara is a reliable choice, as it delivers impressive waterproof performance. This vegan mascara, infused with coconut oil, provides volume and lift while staying put through water sports, sweat, and even showers.

We were amazed to find that it can withstand up to 24 hours of wear without smudging, even after a good cry. While it requires a bit more effort to remove than makeup wipes, the Garnier Micellar Water effectively removes it without damaging the lashes.

To get the most out of this mascara, we recommend wiping down the brush to prevent clumping and avoiding storing it in hot environments, as it can dry out the formula.

Overall, the Eyeko Beach Waterproof Mascara is an excellent choice for those seeking a reliable, long-lasting waterproof option.

Best For: Active individuals seeking a long-lasting, waterproof mascara that can withstand water sports, sweat, and tears.

Pros:

• Provides impressive waterproof performance for up to 24+ hours
• Infused with coconut oil for added nourishment
• Vegan formula

Cons:

• Requires a bit more effort to remove compared to makeup wipes
• Can dry out if stored in hot environments
• Slight smudging on the lower lash line after prolonged wear

Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara

Ideal for those with sensitive eyes, the Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara delivers long-lasting, smudge-proof definition without irritation.

We love how it makes our lashes pop while maintaining a natural look, without any clumping or smearing. The formula is cruelty-free, waterproof, and works well even in hot and humid climates.

Though it doesn't add significant volume, there's no fallout or eyelash stickiness. While we experienced some minor smudging and transfer over time, the mascara remains firmly in place for most of the day.

For those seeking a simple, fuss-free lash look, the Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara is an excellent choice, especially at the discounted price available on Amazon.

Best For: Those with sensitive eyes looking for a long-wearing, smudge-proof mascara that delivers natural definition without irritation.

Pros:

• Cruelty-free, waterproof, and smudge-proof formula
• Makes lashes pop while looking natural, with no clumping or smearing
• Suitable for use in hot and humid climates

Cons:

• May experience some minor smudging and transfer over time
• Does not add significant volume to lashes
• Can sometimes cause slight clumping on the first application

Clinique High Impact Mascara

Those seeking a reliable, sensitive-friendly mascara will find the Clinique High Impact Mascara to be a top contender. We were impressed by how easily it applies and washes off, without any messy clumping.

Despite its dull tube, the formula still performs admirably, delivering long-lasting wear sans smudges or flakes. Our lashes appeared noticeably longer and fuller, thanks to the mascara's volumizing capabilities.

As our eyes have become more sensitive over time, this is the only mascara that doesn't bother us. Satisfied with the results, we'll happily continue using this trusty Clinique staple and recommend it to others in need of a sensitive yet high-impact mascara.

Best For: Individuals with sensitive eyes seeking a long-lasting, volumizing mascara that applies and removes easily.

Pros:

• Easy to apply and wash off
• Helps lashes appear longer and fuller without clumping
• Does not cause irritation for sensitive eyes

Cons:

• Tube appears dull instead of the usual shiny black
• May not be as effective for those seeking extremely bold, dramatic lashes
• Limited shade options compared to some other mascara brands

CLIO Kill Lash Superproof Mascara (02 VOLUME CURLING BLACK)

With its exceptional volume-building and curl-enhancing capabilities, the CLIO Kill Lash Superproof Mascara (02 VOLUME CURLING BLACK) is a standout choice for those seeking a waterproof mascara that delivers dramatic results.

Its smudge-free and clump-free formula effortlessly separates and volumizes each lash, creating a bold, jet-black look that lasts. The strong Curve System technology effectively holds the curl, ensuring our lashes stay lifted and defined throughout the day.

We're impressed by the convenient wand design that makes it easy to reach the lash roots for maximum impact. While the mascara may be slightly pricier, we believe it's worth the investment, especially for those with short, straight Asian lashes that need a boost.

With its long-wearing, waterproof formula, this CLIO mascara is a must-have for anyone seeking a bold, yet flawless eye look.

Best For: The CLIO Kill Lash Superproof Mascara (02 VOLUME CURLING BLACK) is best for those with short, straight Asian lashes who want to achieve dramatic volume, length, and curl.

Pros:

• Smudge-free and clump-free formula that volumizes and separates lashes
• Strong Curve System technology that effectively holds the curl
• Convenient wand design that makes it easy to reach the lash roots

Cons:

• Slightly pricier than some other mascaras
• Can be difficult to remove, requiring a dedicated mascara remover
• May not be as long-lasting as some other waterproof formulas

L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Waterproof Mascara

For those seeking a bold, volumizing waterproof mascara, the L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Waterproof Mascara delivers with its volume-maximizing brush and smudge-resistant formula.

The mascara's unique brush quickly thickens and builds lashes up to 4 times their natural thickness, leaving them separated and defined without any clumps.

The waterproof, flake-proof formula is infused with conditioning ingredients like Panthenol and Ceramide-R, keeping lashes soft and supple all day long.

We love that this mascara is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, making it a versatile option.

Plus, it's an excellent value compared to pricier waterproof mascaras on the market.

Whether you're hitting the pool or braving the elements, this L'Oreal mascara won't budge an inch.

Best For: Those seeking a long-lasting, volumizing waterproof mascara that delivers dramatic lash results without clumping or flaking.

Pros:

• Builds lashes up to 4X their natural thickness
• Waterproof, smudge-resistant formula
• Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers

Cons:

• Flammable until dry
• Should not be applied while driving
• May require a waterproof eye makeup remover for removal

essence Lash Princess Waterproof Mascara

The essence Lash Princess Waterproof Mascara is an excellent choice for those with short, sparse lashes who need a dramatic volume and length boost that can withstand water and humidity. We love its waterproof formula, which provides long-lasting performance and resists smudging and flaking.

The conic-shaped fiber brush delivers great length and volume, while the highly pigmented formula guarantees a rich, non-grey look. While the waterproof version can be tricky to remove, it's worth the effort for those who need a mascara that won't budge, even through swimming or crying.

Many customers rave about this affordable alternative to expensive mascaras, and we agree it's one of the best waterproof options on the market, especially for those with deep-set eyes or who live in humid climates.

Best For: The essence Lash Princess Waterproof Mascara is best for those with short, sparse lashes who need a dramatic volume and length boost that can withstand water and humidity.

Pros:

• Waterproof formula that provides long-lasting performance and resists smudging and flaking
• Conic-shaped fiber brush delivers great length and volume
• Highly pigmented formula guarantees a rich, non-grey look

Cons:

• The waterproof version can be difficult to remove, requiring makeup remover or coconut oil
• May not be suitable for those with oily eyelids
• Some customers find it challenging to achieve the desired look with multiple coats

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara

Offering a unique flex tower brush that bends to volumize and extend every single lash from root to tip, the Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara delivers the full volume and limitless length that beauty enthusiasts seek.

Infused with bamboo extract and fibers, the waterproof formula keeps lashes looking their best even in humid weather, without flaking or smudging.

The precise application and sleek, narrow tube make it easy to achieve a perfect, clump-free look.

Whether you opt for the intensely black or rich brownish-black shade, this mascara enhances your natural lashes for a dramatic, transformative result.

Reviewers widely recommend it as the best drugstore waterproof mascara, praising its ability to condition and nourish lashes with a serum-infused formula that's easy to remove with makeup remover.

Best For: The Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara is best for those seeking full volume, limitless length, and long-lasting, water-resistant hold for their lashes.

Pros:

• Exclusive flex tower brush bends to volumize and extend lashes
• Infused with bamboo extract and fibers for conditioning and nourishment
• Provides dramatic, transformative results without clumping

Cons:

• May need to be reapplied more frequently throughout the day
• Tinted formula may not suit all skin tones or eye colors
• Removal can be more difficult than non-waterproof mascaras

Factors to Consider When Choosing Waterproof Mascara

When choosing a waterproof mascara, you'll want to evaluate its waterproof performance, ease of removal, tendency to clump or flake, longevity and transfer resistance, and suitability for sensitive eyes.

These factors can make a big difference in how the mascara looks and wears throughout the day.

Take them into account to find the best waterproof mascara for your needs.

Waterproof Performance

To achieve the best waterproof performance, you'll want to think about key factors like water-resistance, lash curl hold, and long-wear capabilities. An effective waterproof mascara should resist water, sweat, tears, and humidity without smudging, flaking, or transferring. It needs to maintain your lashes' curl and separation throughout the day without weighing them down.

Long-lasting waterproof performance is vital for activities like swimming, a day at the beach, or outdoor sports. You'll want a formula that stays intact even after crying or showering, without requiring frequent reapplication. The degree of waterproof performance can vary, so it's important to find a mascara that suits your specific needs and lifestyle.

Whether you're after 24-hour, swim-proof, or cry-proof wear, the right waterproof mascara will give you the long-lasting, budge-proof results you need. Consider your daily activities and choose a formula that can truly stand up to whatever comes your way.

Removal Ease

While the waterproof performance of a mascara is essential, you'll also want to evaluate how easily it can be removed when choosing the right formula. Waterproof mascaras generally require more effort to take off than regular ones, often needing special makeup removers or oil-based cleansers. This can be a downside, as some formulas can be stubborn and leave behind residue or smudging, even after thorough cleansing. Rubbing the delicate eye area aggressively to remove waterproof mascara can also lead to irritation and damage.

Fortunately, the removal ease can vary across different waterproof mascara products. Using the right makeup removal technique, such as gently massaging the lashes, can help facilitate the process. Some formulas may be easier to wash off than others, so it's worth doing your research to find a waterproof mascara that provides the longevity you need without being a hassle to remove.

Finding the right balance between waterproof performance and removal ease is key for lush, smudge-free lashes that are easy to achieve and maintain.

Clumping and Flaking

Clumping and flaking can be common issues with waterproof mascaras, especially those formulated with silicones and waxes that may require careful application to avoid uneven coverage. You'll want to look for a mascara with a smooth, creamy consistency to minimize these problems. Overly dry formulas are more prone to flaking and fallout throughout the day, so try to avoid them.

Proper application techniques can go a long way in preventing clumping and flaking. Wiping off excess product from the wand before applying can help guarantee an even, clump-free look. Moreover, storing your waterproof mascara at room temperature and avoiding excessive pumping of the wand can help extend the product's longevity and performance.

Longevity and Transfer

When selecting a waterproof mascara, you'll want to examine its durability and capacity to resist transfer, as these factors can vastly influence the product's performance. Waterproof formulas use silicone-based polymers and waxes to create a protective film around your lashes, helping them withstand humidity, oil production, and even eye-rubbing. However, this barrier doesn't guarantee the mascara will stay put indefinitely. Environmental conditions and your own lash-care habits can impact longevity.

Prolonged wear often leads to transfer, causing the formula to migrate from your upper to lower lash line. This can result in panda-eye smudging, which can be tricky to remove without irritating your eyes.

To maintain your mascara's integrity, be sure to use a dedicated eye makeup remover when it's time to take it off. With the right formula and proper removal techniques, you can enjoy long-lasting, flawless lashes that resist budging, no matter what your day has in store.

Sensitive Eye Suitability

Choosing a waterproof mascara suitable for sensitive eyes requires considering the formula's gentleness, as harsh ingredients can potentially cause irritation or discomfort. Look for waterproof options that are ophthalmologist-tested and hypoallergenic, as these are designed to minimize the risk of eye sensitivity. Formulas containing fewer irritating additives like fragrance, alcohol, and preservatives are typically better suited for delicate peepers.

You'll also want to check if the waterproof mascara is safe for contact lens wearers, as this indicates it's gentle enough for the eyes. Opt for nourishing formulas infused with ingredients like vitamin E, castor oil, and peptides, as these can be less drying and soothing for sensitive eyes.

Before committing, always do a patch test on the inner eyelid to verify your eyes don't react negatively to the mascara. With the right waterproof pick, you can achieve long-lasting, budge-proof lashes without sacrificing eye comfort.

Volumizing and Lengthening

To achieve the volumizing and lengthening benefits you desire from a waterproof mascara, look for formulas infused with nourishing ingredients that can condition lashes while plumping and extending them. Mascaras containing biotin, keratin, and vitamins will help strengthen and moisturize your lashes, giving you the appearance of fuller, longer fringe.

The brush shape and bristle density can also impact a mascara's ability to build up volume and length. Opt for a waterproof formula with a brush designed to grab onto each lash and coat them evenly from root to tip.

Layering waterproof mascara or using it in combination with a lash primer can further enhance these volumizing and lengthening effects. By properly applying the mascara from base to tip, you'll maximize the benefits of the formula, creating the voluminous, elongated lashes you crave, no matter the weather or activity.

Value and Affordability

Besides achieving voluminous, lengthened lashes, you'll also want to weigh the value and affordability when selecting a waterproof mascara that fits your budget.

Fortunately, you don't have to break the bank to get long-lasting, waterproof results. Many budget-friendly drugstore brands offer affordable waterproof mascara options that can rival the performance of high-end prestige products.

When comparing prices, consider the worth you're getting for your money. Some more expensive waterproof mascaras may not necessarily outperform less costly alternatives with respect to longevity, waterproofing, and lash enhancement.

Look for sales, discounts, and coupons to maximize your savings and snag a quality waterproof mascara at a discounted price.

Ultimately, you'll want to find the right balance between your budget and the benefits of the waterproof mascara. While splurging on a pricier option may be tempting, the higher cost doesn't always equate to considerably better performance or results.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Waterproof Mascara Require Specific Removal Techniques?

Yes, waterproof mascara does require specific removal techniques.

Unlike regular mascara, waterproof formulas are designed to be long-lasting and resistant to water, sweat, and tears. To remove it effectively, you'll need to use an oil-based makeup remover or micellar water.

Gently massage the remover over your lashes, let it sit for a minute, then gently wipe away the mascara. Avoid tugging or rubbing too hard, as this can lead to lash damage.

With the right technique, you can easily remove waterproof mascara without issue.

How Do I Prevent Smudging With Waterproof Mascara?

To prevent smudging with waterproof mascara, start by curling your lashes before applying.

Use a light hand and apply the mascara in thin, even coats, avoiding clumping. Let each coat dry completely before adding another.

To remove, use a dedicated eye makeup remover or micellar water on a cotton pad. Gently wipe away the mascara, taking care not to tug or rub your eyes.

With the right application and removal techniques, you can keep your lashes looking fresh all day long.

Can Waterproof Mascara Be Used on Sensitive Eyes?

Waterproof mascara can be used on sensitive eyes, but you'll want to choose a formula that's gentle and hypoallergenic. Look for mascaras labeled 'sensitive' or 'ophthalmologist-tested.'

Avoid formulas with harsh chemicals, and be sure to remove it properly at the end of the day to prevent irritation.

With the right waterproof mascara, you can enjoy long-lasting, smudge-free wear without sacrificing eye comfort.

Is Waterproof Mascara Suitable for Short or Sparse Lashes?

Waterproof mascara can be a great option for those with short or sparse lashes. It provides extra volume and length, helping to define and enhance your natural lashes.

The waterproof formula also helps prevent smudging or flaking, which can be a concern for those with finer lashes. Just be sure to use a gentle eye makeup remover to avoid any irritation when removing the mascara at the end of the day.

How Long Does Waterproof Mascara Typically Last Before Needing Replacement?

Waterproof mascara typically lasts around 3-6 months before needing replacement. It's crucial to replace it regularly, as the formula can dry out over time, leading to clumping and flaking.

Be sure to store your waterproof mascara properly, keeping it away from heat and moisture to extend its lifespan. Remember to remove it thoroughly at the end of the day to prevent damage to your lashes.

With proper care, you can enjoy long-lasting, smudge-proof wear from your waterproof mascara.